Blogs

Blog 300- Hey Extension Students, Your Jobs Are Stolen

In this blog, Alagu Niranjan urges extension graduates in India to explore employment opportunities outside academia and government.

Over the past 3+ years at CRISP, I’ve done research, knowledge management, website management, volunteer coordination, and mentored and recruited interns and research assistants. This journey has taught me many lessons. One is that extension graduates are often left out of the vast research and development job market.

The title, “your jobs are stolen”, can be misleading if you take it literally. However, many job opportunities where extension graduates (having MSc and PhD degrees in agricultural extension) would perform best go to graduates with multiple different degrees but similar skills. By “different degrees,” I mean courses that don’t require agriculture as a core subject but do teach skills like conducting literature reviews, collecting and analysing both qualitative and quantitative field data, and writing reports (especially for different audiences). In short, neither the job market nor the recruiter cares whether you have an agriculture degree. If you don’t understand this, you won’t move forward and find jobs that are more rewarding than academic jobs in government institutions.

While reviewing applications for CRISP’s Internships and Research Assistant/Associate positions, I noticed a few interesting patterns that contrast our extension graduates from others.

  1. You are not trying: Only 2 of 10 applications are from extension graduates. This shows you are not even competing for positions that can offer a different worldview.
  2. You are not presenting well: Among those who apply, many are not reading the job description well and are not customising their CVs Rather, you share a poorly formatted recent CV of yours without a proper email subject and message. Though you may have the skills needed for the position, your presentation makes your skills and experience hard to find in the CV.
  3. You are not speaking confidently: Very few extension graduates who enter the discussion/interview part of the recruitment are speaking confidently. This may be because our ICAR/SAU system discourages you from communicating confidently with seniors and staff. During an interview with one of the extension graduates, I noticed the candidate could not move away from their research topic and work. For every question, even the personality-related ones, their responses connected to their PhD research.
  4. You don’t have any work experience: The other 8 of 10 applicants are not perfect, but they have something to show on their CV. Many of them had multiple short internships (1-3 months) from multiple organisations.

If you are not trying, presenting and communicating well, and building work experience, your skills and knowledge will have no meaning or space in the non-governmental sector. Some of you may think, “I am preparing for ARS and Assistant Professor Positions; why should I care?”

Here are some interesting data points. My estimate, based on last year’s ICAR AICE (31st) Online Counselling Brochure-2026 for PG and PhD positions in Extension (all branches), is that the ICAR/SAU system alone admits over 750 PG and 400 PhD students. This does not include private universities and non-accredited agricultural universities.

This means over 1200 students graduate from PG and PhD programmes in extension education in India each year. However, last year’s ARS notification offered only 28 ARS positions and 4 SMS positions, for a total of 32 vacancies. Even if we hypothetically assume that SAUs advertise five times as many Assistant Professor positions as the number of ARS and SMS vacancies combined, that would translate into only 160 university positions annually. Let us be generous and round this up to 200 vacancies a year. Compare that with the more than 1,200 students graduating from PG and PhD programmes in extension education each year. The gap between candidates entering the job market and potential openings is hard to ignore.

Some of you may still say, “I only need one job, and I will be among those 200”.

I respect your confidence. However, the reality might not support that confidence. If you have to make 3-5 ARS attempts and 8-10 AP interviews and still cannot make it, you’ll not only lose a job but also years with your family. Not everyone will have the privilege of making 3+ ARS attempts and 8+ AP interviews. So, it is better to start early and explore opportunities on the other side.

If you are wondering where to start, last year we at AESA organised a Panel Discussion on “Beyond Traditional Roles: Career Options for Extension Graduates” to show our extension graduates the other way.  Explore the meeting video and the notes online.

Also, start working on the 4 observations I made at the beginning of this blog.

  1. Start trying: Please start applying for the positions where part of you can fit in. It is like getting on the metro or bus during peak hours. Just try to put yourself in the position of applying and appearing for an interview. Do not look for words such as “extension” or “agriculture” in the job descriptions. Apply if you find keywords such as field research, facilitation, training, communication, data analysis, report writing, etc. Follow pages that showcase job opportunities in the NGO and Private Sector where you could fit, for example, “AESA Suggests” on LinkedIn.
  2. Present yourself better: Do not use boring Times New Roman fonts and stale tables in your CVs Also, do not make your CV run for 8-10 pages. Make it short, crisp and palatable. Beyond presenting yourself well on paper (CV), present yourself well in the interview: dress well, speak audibly, and sit in proper lighting (if appearing online).
  3. Speak confidently: Do not hesitate to describe your work experiences. The interviewers are not there to listen to what is already in your CV. Be real when answering questions exploring your personality (for example, a question about your level of curiosity and reading habits).
  4. Start interning: Do not rest during the semester holidays. Go to the nearest NGOs or Private organisations for internships/ volunteering. Have something beyond your degree in your CV.

To conclude, your jobs aren’t stolen; you just never bothered to explore what is on the other side.

Dr D. Alagu Niranjan is a Research and Knowledge Management Officer with the Centre for Research on Innovation and Science Policy (CRISP), Hyderabad, India. He also manages AESA’s Knowledge Management and Volunteer Programme. He can be reached at alaguniranjan@crispindia.org.

 

TO DOWNLOAD AS PDF CLICK HERE

10 Comments

Click here to post a comment

  • A very insightful and thought-provoking read! What particularly stood out to me is the need to look beyond conventional career pathways in Agricultural Extension. Often, students invest years in acquiring academic qualifications, but the transition from academic learning to professional opportunities remains a challenge.

    I appreciate how this article draws attention to the importance of practical exposure, relevant skills, internships, and exploring opportunities across different sectors. Agricultural Extension is much broader than we often perceive, and its interdisciplinary nature offers graduates several avenues to contribute to research, rural development, innovation, and the agricultural sector.

    I believe the real shift begins when we stop viewing a degree merely as a qualification and start recognising it as a foundation for creating value in different professional spaces.

    Thank you, Dr. D. Alagu Niranjan Sir , for addressing such a relevant concern and encouraging young extension professionals to rethink their career possibilities.

  • An apt and thought-provoking blog by Dr. Alagu sir! A timely reminder that opportunities in agricultural extension extend far beyond academia and government jobs. While job security is important, pursuing our passion, creating meaningful impact and finding fulfilment in our work matter equally. Sometimes, the right career is not necessarily the most conventional one!

    The 300th AESA blog is yet another remarkable milestone, reflecting AESA’s invaluable contribution to knowledge sharing and shaping perspectives in agricultural extension.

    A wonderful read that encourages young professionals to think beyond conventional career paths, explore possibilities and redefine professional success. Thanks to AESA!

  • An insightful and thought-provoking article! The message is timely and important for all Agricultural Extension students and young scholars. A degree alone is no longer sufficient; we must also develop practical skills, gain field experience, strengthen our communication abilities, and explore opportunities beyond traditional academic and government positions. Agricultural Extension professionals have immense potential in research, development organisations, NGOs, CSR initiatives, project management, and the private sector.

    It is time to broaden our career perspectives, recognise our transferable skills, and proactively prepare ourselves for emerging opportunities. The jobs are not necessarily stolen; perhaps we need to expand our vision, upgrade our skills, and step beyond our comfort zones. Kudos to AESA and Dr. Alagu Niranjan for initiating this much-needed conversation!

  • A very useful blog highlighting competency gaps among agricultural extension PG and PhD graduates.

    Although I am not directly involved in the extension job market, my experience in research methods capacity building, managing IP and technology commercialisation, and implementing field interventions reinforces the need for extension graduates to blend core extension competencies with technical, managerial, and entrepreneurial skills.

    Emerging jobs in agricultural development increasingly focus on creating and managing value chains, building resilience, strengthening livelihoods, and promoting social inclusion. These demand competencies in facilitating change—understanding farmers’ decision-making, influencing technology adoption, communicating for behavioural change, mobilising communities, building partnerships, researching and documenting change, managing human resources, developing markets, and designing and implementing effective interventions.

    Few globally developed approaches such as PMCA, Mother–Baby Trials, recommendation domains, and participatory impact pathways offer valuable frameworks, yet are rarely taught as applied competencies.

    Building these competencies through university-based education remains a major challenge, as students often have limited opportunities to engage with real-world development problems and learn through field interventions. Textbooks provide theoretical foundations but rarely teach when, where, and how to apply them.

    Extension education must move beyond knowledge acquisition towards experiential, competency-based learning that prepares graduates as facilitators of change, while broadening their career aspirations beyond conventional white-collar government jobs to emerging opportunities in agribusiness, development projects, technology commercialisation, entrepreneurship, and rural livelihood development”.

    I would also like to add a few more points to this important discussion on the employability and professional competencies of agricultural extension graduates.

    Every postgraduate and doctoral student in agriculture is expected to acquire discipline-specific competencies that distinguish them from graduates of other disciplines and expand their employment opportunities. For example, biotechnologists develop expertise in molecular markers and DNA fingerprinting; plant breeders acquire laboratory and field-based breeding techniques; entomologists learn insect identification, pheromone development and pesticide formulation; food technologists gain expertise in response surface methodology (RSM), proximate analysis and shelf-life extension; and agricultural economists develop competencies in price policy analysis, estimation of returns on investment and economic evaluation.

    These competencies go beyond theoretical knowledge. They involve the ability to select, implement and interpret specific methods and technologies using laboratory equipment, field procedures and analytical techniques.

    What, then, are the distinctive professional competencies of agricultural extension graduates?

    To my understanding, these include:

    •⁠ ⁠Technology assessment and refinement: Applying systematic approaches such as scaling readiness, recommendation domains and participatory technology evaluation to assess, adapt and scale agricultural innovations.
    •⁠ ⁠Communication for behavioural change: Designing context-specific communication interventions using appropriate instructional design strategies and methods of influencing technology adoption.
    •⁠ ⁠Entrepreneurship and value chain development: Conducting market research, identifying business opportunities, preparing detailed project reports (DPRs), developing business models and facilitating market linkages.
    •⁠ ⁠Facilitation of change: Combining agricultural knowledge with extension approaches to engage stakeholders, strengthen institutions, build partnerships and facilitate collective action.
    •⁠ ⁠Capacity building: Applying systematic training needs assessment, instructional planning, experiential learning methods and training evaluation techniques.
    •⁠ ⁠Social and field research: Selecting and implementing appropriate qualitative, quantitative and mixed-methods research designs, including rigorous data collection, analysis and interpretation.

    Unlike many laboratory-based competencies, these extension competencies are predominantly field-based. They cannot be developed adequately through classroom instruction, textbooks or examinations alone. They require sustained engagement with farmers, communities, markets, institutions and other stakeholders, along with opportunities to design, implement and evaluate real-world interventions.

    In India, institutions such as TISS (Mumbai and Tuljapur), IRMA, MANAGE (through its management programmes), IIMs, IITs and certain private institutions produce graduates with strong competencies in field research, development management, programme implementation, entrepreneurship, institutional development and consulting. Many of these graduates compete successfully for the professional positions highlighted by Dr Alagu Niranjan in his blog.

    Consulting firms such as Grant Thornton, EY and McKinsey also recruit professionals with such competencies to undertake high-value government, development-sector and private-sector assignments. These opportunities increasingly require professionals who can diagnose development problems, design practical interventions, manage stakeholders, build inclusive value chains, facilitate behavioural and institutional change, and demonstrate measurable impact.

    The fundamental question, therefore, is whether our agricultural extension departments are preparing their postgraduate and doctoral graduates to meet the competency requirements of these emerging, high-value professional job markets.

    We need to move beyond preparing students primarily for conventional government and academic positions. Agricultural extension has a distinctive professional identity and considerable potential in development consulting, agribusiness, entrepreneurship, value chain management, rural transformation and impact-oriented development programmes.

    The challenge is not merely to expand employment opportunities for extension graduates, but to develop graduates whose distinctive competencies make them genuinely competitive for these opportunities. This requires rethinking how extension competencies are taught, practised and assessed, with much greater emphasis on field immersion, hands-on methodological training and demonstrated ability to facilitate change.

  • First, I would like to appreciate Dr. Alagu Niranjan for having touched upon an important issue and shed light and to visualise what is in store for Extension graduates.

    Bountiful appreciations to Dr. Mahesh Chander and Dr. Sethuraman for spending time in highlighting the importance of this blog.

    Dr. Sethuraman is known for his out of box comments which he exhibited more eloquently in his message and these comments resemble another blog on this topic.

  • To be honest, many Extension graduates are living under the illusion that they will easily get an Assistant Professor or ARS position. We need to wake up to reality and understand the gap between the number of vacancies and the number of graduates.

    Even candidates with a PhD and international publications are sometimes not shortlisted for interviews. I have been a mute spectator to all this and have spoken about it many times.
    Today, I would simply say: don’t live in an illusion.” Understand the reality, adapt, and find your own path. I wish the system should reward those at least who are putting sincere effort and hard work into doing something great in this field; otherwise, people will lose faith from this system.

  • Salute to Dr Alagu Niranjana for such an analytical approach on employability of extension pass outs.

  • Thank you, Dr Alagu Niranjan sir, for such an honest blog.
    As a PhD scholar working on agri-entrepreneurship, I see this from both sides. Many of us in the extension keep waiting for the next ARS cycle, while the wider job market goes unexplored. Your numbers (1,200+ graduates for roughly 200 openings) make the reality clear. I also liked that you gave practical fixes: apply by skill keywords, build a crisp CV, speak with confidence and intern early.
    Every extension student should read this before deciding where to put the next few years. Congratulations on AESA’s 300th blog!

  • A very relevant discussion, especially for young agricultural graduates facing increasing competition for limited opportunities. We need to move beyond traditional career expectations, strengthen our practical and transferable skills, and explore opportunities across research, development and the private sector. Agricultural extension has much more potential than we often realise!